New Script Version for Sherlock Holmes 3
The director's position is still open
After a waiting period of over 13 years, it seems that things are finally moving forward: A new script version for "Sherlock Holmes 3" is now on the table.
The first two "Sherlock Holmes" movies starring Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law were a huge success – in fact, combined they grossed over a billion dollars. A third part was therefore as good as certain, but it is yet to be made.
Now there is reason to hope: in an interview with The Playlist, Watson actor Jude Law revealed that a new version of the script was finally available. He also emphasized that everyone involved is still committed to making part 3. However, there are still some unresolved matters, such as the production costs and the feasibility of the project.
The long-lasting friendship with Robert Downey Jr. and his wife Susan is one of the main reasons for Law to be involved in a third part of the detective saga. Nevertheless, we will probably need to remain patient for a while longer: The director's position is still vacant, and Robert Downey Jr. should have enough on his plate with his role as Dr. Doom in the MCU for the time being anyway.
The Sherlock Holmes films with Robert Downey Jr. – A modern adventure of the master detective story
Guy Ritchie's "Sherlock Holmes" films from 2009 and 2011 gave the legendary character of the master detective a fresh new look. Starring Robert Downey Jr. as Sherlock Holmes and Jude Law as his faithful partner Dr. John Watson, the films combine Victorian charm, action-packed scenes and a touch of humor. At a time when classic literary adaptations were often restrained, these films brought an unexpected dynamism and visual opulence to the world of the most famous detective in literary history.
Sherlock Holmes (2009): An explosive opening
The first film, simply titled "Sherlock Holmes", takes the viewer into a gloomy but lively London of the late 19th century. Holmes and Watson are at the center of a mysterious case that leads them on the trail of Lord Blackwood (played by Mark Strong) , a seemingly supernatural villain who spreads fear and terror through occult practices.
The movie opens with a powerful staging: a dark ritual scene that interrupts Holmes and Watson. It quickly becomes clear that this Sherlock Holmes is not only analytically brilliant, but also physically well-trained – a departure from the more intellectual character previously portrayed in films and series. Robert Downey Jr. gives Holmes a gruff, charming and often eccentric personality. As Watson, Jude Law brings the necessary down-to-earthness and loyalty to balance out Holmes' impulsive behavior.
The movie's plot is a clever blend of classic detective drama and modern blockbuster action cinema. Holmes' deductive skills are emphasized not only by his powers of observation, but also by strategic fight scenes, which are shown in slow motion in Ritchie's typical style. At the same time, the film stays true to the spirit of the original by emphasizing Holmes' intellect and Watson's role as a moral compass.
Visually, the film impresses with its detailed reconstruction of Victorian London. From dark alleyways to dimly lit pubs and magnificent mansions, every backdrop looks authentic and lively. Hans Zimmer's unmistakable film music contributes to this, underlining the unconventional nature of the main character with its quirky yet catchy sound.
Sherlock Holmes: A Games of Shadows (2011): The bigger hit
The sequel, "Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows", continues the story with an even bigger and more ambitious plot. This time, Holmes and Watson face the legendary nemesis Professor Moriarty (Jared Harris). Moriarty, an equally brilliant and unscrupulous opponent, plans to trigger the First World War prematurely through political intrigue and the establishment of an arms empire.
While the first film focused heavily on the introduction of the characters and the atmosphere, Game in the Shadows expands the world of Holmes and Watson. The action shifts out of London and into the European countryside, with locations in Paris, Germany and the snow-capped Alps. This geographical expansion gives the story an epic dimension.
The tone of the film is darker and more menacing, which is reinforced by Moriarty's cold-blooded intelligence. Jared Harris succeeds in giving Moriarty an underlying menace that makes him a match for Holmes. The conflict between the two becomes particularly clear in a game of chess at the end of the film, which serves as a metaphor for their intellectual debate.
The dynamic between Holmes and Watson is also convincing in this movie. Watson's personal development – his marriage and the resulting new phase in his life – is sensitively portrayed, while Holmes struggles to continue their journey together. Rachel McAdams as Irene Adler and Noomi Rapace as the mysterious gypsy Simza bring additional tension and dynamism to the plot.
As in the first film, Guy Ritchie relies on stylized action sequences and impressive visual effects. One highlight is a spectacular chase through a forest in which explosions, bullets and slow-motion effects merge into a visually thrilling sequence.
A modern take on a classic hero
The two films are characterized by a clever balance between tradition and innovation. On the one hand, they honor Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's literary model by focusing on Holmes' powers of deduction, his sarcasm and his complex relationship with Watson. On the other hand, they modernize the character with humorous dialogue, action-packed scenes and a fast-paced narrative style that makes it accessible to a modern audience.
The chemistry between Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law is particularly noteworthy. Their portrayal of an almost brotherly friendship is the emotional heart of the films. While Holmes is often portrayed as a lonely, socially awkward intellectual, these films show him as someone who is brilliant but also humanly flawed - a man who would be lost without Watson's support.